A dated, measured record that the power path was checked under known load and no connection stood out from its matching parts. That is the baseline next year’s survey is compared against, evidence for your insurer, auditor or client, and a list of exactly what was imaged and what wasn’t. A clean result is still a result.
Facilities and critical engineering teams sometimes ask this after a survey comes back with nothing to fix. It is a fair question. The answer depends on whether the report proves the survey was done properly, because a clean result is only worth something if you can see what it covered and under what load.
What a clean report should still show
- The asset list. Every switchboard, UPS, static transfer switch, busbar run and PDU surveyed, by name and location, so you can see the route followed the power path (see the whole power path, intake to rack).
- The load at the time. The current reading for each board or UPS when it was imaged. Without it, nobody can tell whether the equipment was working hard enough for a poor connection to show (see what load a survey needs).
- A not-imaged list. Anything that could not be opened or reached on the day, with the reason, so it can be picked up later.
- Who did it. The thermographer’s name and certification level.
Why a clean result has value
It is your baseline. Next year’s survey is compared with this one, board by board and at a similar load. A connection that has warmed since then is easier to spot and to explain (see comparing results year on year).
It is evidence. Insurers, auditors and colocation customers ask what condition monitoring is in place. A dated report showing the power path was surveyed under load is a straight answer.
At commissioning, it is part of handover. A clean result under load bank test is a record that the joints carried test load without standing out, signed off before the installer leaves (see commissioning thermography vs the annual survey).
When a clean result should prompt questions
- Low load. On a dual-fed site each side may carry well under its rating. If the load isn’t recorded, a clean result can’t be relied on (see enough load on a 2N site).
- Covers left on. Imaging the outside of a closed panel tells you little about the connections inside. Check how many boards were actually opened.
- Short coverage. If the survey stopped at the switch room, the busbar, tap-offs and PDUs in the halls were not checked.
- Shiny metal. Bare copper and polished surfaces reflect heat from elsewhere. An experienced thermographer reads these correctly; a less experienced one can miss a warm joint or report a false one.
What it does not tell you
A survey is a snapshot at the load of that day. It does not replace torque checks, maintenance or protection testing (see torque checks vs thermography), and conditions change when load rises or a new customer goes live (see surveying again after a load increase).
The same method finds problems when they are there
On a London data centre build, commissioning thermography by our team found 16 busbar sections reading above 80 °C under test load, the highest 103.5 °C at a tap-off unit (see busbar thermography at commissioning). A clean report from the same method, at a recorded load, is worth having for the same reason: you know it was looked at properly. Ti inspects and reports, and we deliver reports the same day.
Frequently asked questions
If we get clean results, can we survey less often?
The interval should follow the site’s risk, load changes and insurer requirements. One clean year is a good sign, not proof that nothing will change.
Should a clean report include images?
It should at least list every asset surveyed with its load. If you want images of equipment with no findings, write that into the scope so every bidder prices it.
Does a clean result mean the thermographer missed something?
Not if the load was recorded, the panels were opened and the whole path was covered. Those three things are what to check in the report.
Related reading
- Data centre electrical thermography
- Switchgear thermography
- Annual PPM electrical thermography
- 7 electrical risks thermography finds
- How quickly you should get the report
Ti Thermal Imaging’s surveys are carried out by ITC Level 3 thermographers, and Ti is a Level 3 certified company. Our work has featured on BBC News and ITV.
Talk to us: +44 20 3885 7464 · sales@thermalimaging.co.uk · contact page
About the author: Rachael Browning, General Manager, Ti Thermal Imaging.